Saturday, March 20, 2010

Perry's Scheme & Project II

Writing an argument is different from speaking an argument. When writing, you're trying to win by persuading the readers that you have valid points and that those points are better suited for a certain situation. You do that by appealing to the readers using Ethos, Pathos and Logos and by proving that you understand the opposing views. When writing an argument, you have to be two people. First, you have to be yourself so you can express your views and your side of the argument. Second, you have to be your opponent so you can better persuade your readers to accept your views. You have to literally argue with yourself. Writing is also less personal.
When speaking an argument, you don't have to be two people. Unless you're giving a speech about an issue, you will have an opponent to argue with. It's more personal because you can look your opponent in the eye when you're arguing. You're speaking to someone and you're having a conversation. You can also tell how you're doing by observing your opponent's facial expressions and body language. But you have to be able to work under pressure when speaking an argument. You never know what your opponent might do.
But whether you're speaking or writing an argument, you're trying to appeal to your audience and get them to take your side on a certain issue. You're persuading them and convincing them that your views and ideas are the better ones.

I don't think I stand on just one part of the spectrum of Perry's Scheme. I might be at the "Pre-Commitment" stage because I see the necessity of making choices and committing to something but I don't always commit. I tend to do the assignment that appeals to me most and sounds most interesting. And I tend to avoid and procrastinate on the subjects that I have no interest in or that I find tedious and annoying. That is not the case for this class. I find this class very interesting and project II was fun. The topic I chose was interesting and that motivated me to write. It's so much better than to doing Chemistry homework.

1 comment:

  1. excellent work Sarah. Very good insights here...if i remember or plan well i'll use this as a model or as a discussion point for us.

    jeff

    ReplyDelete